Showing posts with label Sonia Sotomayor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sonia Sotomayor. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Inference Engine and Applications

Inference Engine

One of the things that internet/web enables is to make low-cost data collection and analysis mostly a computational question. Add in the idea of "wisdom of crowd", then you have the making of PARC's inference engine technology - if you would allow for a gross simplification.

What the inference engine is good at is to identify items that may be linked in ways that is not always obvious. My favorite example is how the inference engine easily cracked the heavily redacted story on the location of a CIA agent's first assignment in How to catch a spy.

Web Chatters

But the same technique can also be used to identify emerging trends (chatters) on a specific topic. So, I used the Inference Engine to look at the top terms associated with the Sonia Sotomayor's nomination process to the US Supreme Court at Sotomayor Web Chatter Index.

And, indeed, it is interesting to see what are the top ranking terms associated with that process and how it points to specific concepts that come in and out of favor in the web crowd.

Private Corpus

Finally, it may be worth noting that the same technique can also be applied to data corpus beyond the visible internet. For example, eDiscovery in legal proceeding is a space where this capability would be very helpful by expanding beyond simple keyword search to a more nuanced understanding of how information linked to each other.

===
P@P

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 12

New items and faded topics

The term "111th" which refers to the fact that Justice Sotomayor is the 111th for the Supreme Court, continued its appearance in the top 20.

For the first time, "Malesko" and "Alito" both showed up in all three rankings. Would this presage the basis for the first analysis of the Supreme Court once she is sworn in and decisions are rendered?

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

sonija

leval

sotomyaor

judgeship

rulings

111th

stating

sotomayor

coxe

gurfein

gop

malesko

judging

68-31

chin

ginsburg

ruled

eight

legislator

alito


sotomyaor

sotomayor

sonia

souter

malesko

mcmahon

destefano

bronxdale

alito

ginsburg

hispanic

scotus

nominee

scotusblog

supreme

scalia

hearings

morgenthau

111th

allowing


sotomayor

alito

scotus

moynihan

obama

statehood

souter

111th

rulings

destefano

retiring

scalia

stating

legislator

ginsburg

malesko

cabranes

scotusblog

mahoney

rendell



===
P@P

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 11

Confirmed to the US Supreme Court

By a vote of 68-31, Sonia Sotomayor was confirmed as a Supreme Court justice on August 6th, 2009.

New items and faded topics

All the usual suspects such as "nlj (National Law Journal)", Foxnews, and "wsj.com" dropped off the top 20 list.

The new term that is making a rapid ascend is the term "111th" which, in case you missed the news, Justice Sotomayor is the 111th for the supreme court.

Next week, we will have the final installment on the top 20 analyses.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

sotomyaor

stating

sotomayor

rulings

sonia

faced

sued

assail

baer

gop

coxe

111th

gurfein

meant

approval

involving

judging

â

nominees

murders


sotomyaor

sotomayor

sonia

souter

malesko

judgepedia

mcmahon

destefano

bronxdale

alito

scotus

ginsburg

scotusblog

nominee

hispanic

supreme

judgeship

hearings

morgenthau

tasini


alito

sotomayor

obamaâ

scotus

moynihan

obama

statehood

111th

souter

scotusblog

retiring

destefano

malesko

legislator

politico

cabranes

noting

mahoney

stating

judgeship



===
P@P

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 10

Senate Confirmation Debate

Now that the Senate Judiciary Committee has endorsed the Supreme Court nomination of Judge Sonia Sotomayor, the nomination is now in the full Senate for debate.

New items and faded topics

The term "nlj (National Law Journal)" and its sister term "pubarticlenlj.jsp" have kept up its ranking. As a matter of a fact, it shot up to #1 in one of the engine results.

Foxnews has quickly lost its top 20 ranking while "wsj.com" continues to assert its relevance to this discussion. Also appearing for the first time is the term "Barack" and debuting as #1 no less. Similarly, "conservatives" made its top 20 appearance.

Finally, the term "dissented" which appeared in the top 20 last week kept its position this week.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

justices

stating

cityâ

rulings

dissented

sotomayor

sotomayorâ

questioning

proceedings

defenses

nominees

malesko

krimstock

â

supporting

issued

ended

nearly

senator

supreme


nlj

sotomayor

sotomayorâ

krimstock

sonia

malesko

souter

pubarticlenlj.jsp

destefano

ginsburg

scotusblog

nominee

hispanic

judgeship

supreme

judgepedia

hostednews

jury

hearings

leahy


barack

sotomayor

moynihan

statehood

obama

leahy

souter

cuomo

destefano

cabranes

scotusblog

online.wsj.com

ginsburg

conservatives

affirmative

prosecutor

stating

nlj

rulings

politico



===
P@P

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 9

Senate Judiciary Committee Confirmation

The Senate Judiciary Committee voted, 13 to 6, today to endorse the Supreme Court nomination of Judge Sonia Sotomayor

New items and faded topics

The term "nlj" which refers to "National Law Journal", has kept up its ranking and added a related term "pubarticlenlj.jsp" "judgepedia" - a wiki on judges - kept its place.

Foxnews has come back with a vagence as #3 on Google. On the other hand, Washingtonpost.com disappeared from the top 20 ranking. "wsj.com" continues to do well losing one notch, edged out by "Obama" on Microsoft ranking.

Also interesting is to see the term "dissented" in the top 20. We will see if it would stay next week.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

justices

www.foxnews.com

sotomayorâ

rulings

cityâ

dissented

judiciary

defenses

sotomayor

courts

americans

souter

malesko

hearings

â

senators

circumstances

krimstock

issued

reversal


sonia

sotomayorâ

sotomayor

souter

destefano

krimstock

nominee

ginsburg

nlj

hearings

morgenthau

judgepedia

tasini

leahy

judiciary

malesko

cuomo

judgeship

supreme

justices


sotomayor

statehood

moynihan

obama

leahy

online.wsj.com

nlj

souter

destefano

cuomo

stating

rulings

ginsburg

cabranes

republicans

prosecutor

affirmative

pubarticlenlj.jsp

politico

gained



===
P@P

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 8

Confirmation Hearing

With the confirmation hearing done, it is interesting to see how the discussion has shifted into some factual and some "speculative" terms.

New items and faded topics

"judgepedia" - a wiki on judges - kept its place. It is also joined by the term "nlj" which refers to "National Law Journal"

Foxnews has completely dropped off from the top 20 rankings after being highly ranked for most weeks. Interesting to see Washingtonpost.com making a come back - I wonder if it is a reflection that now the denizens inside the Washington DC Beltway are doing most of the chattering. As for wsj.com's come back, do you have any thoughts?

Also interesting is to see the term "unanimous" in the top 20 which does seem to reflect the mainstream media's consensus on her confirmation.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

justices

repeatedly

stating

americans

sotomayor

questioning

judiciary

dissented

reversing

helped

defenses

lawyers

nyt

â

cityâ

souter

www.washingtonpost.com

saying

became

unconstitutional


sotomayorâ

sotomayor

sonia

souter

krimstock

ginsburg

nominee

judgepedia

nlj

morgenthau

tasini

cuomo

hearings

leahy

judgeship

supreme

justices

judiciary

republicans

hispanic


sotomayor

moynihan

statehood

online.wsj.com

obama

nlj

souter

banc

cuomo

leahy

rulings

politico

gop

stating

reversals

ginsburg

prosecutor

unanimous

affirmative

cabranes



===
P@P

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 7

Confirmation Hearing

Now that the confirmation hearing for Ms Sonia Sotomayor's nomination to the US Supreme Court has started, I am curious to see how the chatter profile would change.

New items and faded topics

"Litigator" did not have the staying power to remain in the top 20. "Firefighters" is also waning. The new entrant to the top ranking is "judgepedia" - a wiki on judges, did not know one existed.

Foxnews has dropped in rankings after being highly ranked for most weeks. Would it come a come back now that the confirmation hearing is now?

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

senators

esquire

judiciary

www.foxnews.com

jury

sotomayorâ

reversing

senator

ruled

dissented

courts

sotomayor

reversal

sued

rulings

nominated

attorney

married

belief

securities


sotomayorâ

sotomayor

sonia

souter

gillibrand

krimstock

ginsburg

schumer

judgepedia

nominee

cuomo

judgeship

justices

morgenthau

supreme

leahy

cabranes

firefighters

www.foxnews.com

republicans


sotomayor

gillibrand

obama

schumer

moynihan

souter

cuomo

rulings

centrist

reversals

politico

gop

republicans

leahy

ginsburg

firefighter

prosecutor

mahoney

cabranes

affirmative



===
P@P

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 7

New items and faded topics

Firefighters made the top 20 list this week. Litigator also made the top 20. Two timely entries on the current discussion. We will see how long they last.

As noted last week, "racist" made an appearance. It disappeared this week and "centrist" actually made its appearance. Gingrich completely dropped off in all three results. Also interesting to note that Foxnews dropped significantly in one of the rankings.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

rulings

www.foxnews.com

dissented

sotomayorâ

sotomayor

souter

litigator

questioning

nominees

krimstock

proceedings

republicans

defenses

â

cityâ

ended

res

judges

reversing

efforts


sotomayor

sotomayorâ

sonia

souter

krimstock

schumer

ginsburg

nominee

cuomo

judgeship

justices

supreme

cabranes

judgepedia

biden

firefighters

hispanic

republicans

www.foxnews.com

leahy


sotomayor

schumer

obama

moynihan

souter

cuomo

rulings

gop

centrist

republicans

politico

reversals

cabranes

ginsburg

firefighters

prosecutor

leahy

affirmative

litigator

nominees



===
P@P

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 6

New items and faded topics

Jarring but interesting to see that "racist" made the top 20 this week. Palin also vaulted to into the top 20 this week. Letterman made a come back to the top 20.

As noted last week, CNN indeed dropped off the list as suspected. Nightline probably did a program on this topic so it made the top 20, we will see if it stays next week. And, finally, instead of making a run for the top spot that Foxnews occupies, Gingrich lost ranking in all three results. It may be time for him to say a few new things.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

sotomayorhtml

www.foxnews.com

justices

sotomayorâ

courts

nominees

facility

concerns

serving

issued

cityâ

ended

ricans

served

moved

rican

hearings

filed

krimstock

sotomayor


www.foxnews.com

sotomayor

sotomayorâ

sonia

souter

online.wsj.com

scotus

scotusblog

gillibrand

gingrich

nominee

judgeship

schumer

ginsburg

supreme

justices

krimstock

nomination

hispanic

racist


scotus

palin

gillibrand

gingrich

schumer

obama

scotusblog

justices

gop

souter

rulings

politico

republicans

nominee

cuomo

blotter

sotomayor

nightline

letterman

unanimous



===
P@P

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 5

New items and faded topics

"Gingrich" is mounting a come back. It has gone up a bit on the ranking in both Yahoo and Microsoft and is just one place shy of making it into the top 20 for the Google result. Interesting to see CNN popping up high in the Yahoo result; I wonder if it will fade next week. Even more interesting, Google show up in the top 20 for Yahoo results. Not sure what is the explanation on that one.

www.foxnews.com retained its #1 ranking in two of the three search engines. I don't suppose Gingrich would make a run for the #1 spot?

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine used in this analysis, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

www.foxnews.com

justices

rulings

defenses

sotomayorâ

questioning

dissented

nominees

sotomayor

circumstances

schumer

fourth

krimstock

souter

cityâ

ended

activist

judges

efforts

rican


www.foxnews.com

sotomayor

sotomayorâ

www.cnn.com

sonia

souter

www.newsday.com

gingrich

nominee

schumer

ginsburg

judgeship

nlj

cuomo

krimstock

supreme

justices

www.google.com

hispanic

republicans


schumer

gingrich

justices

obama

gop

souter

defenses

cuomo

sotomayor

republicans

rulings

democrats

nominee

politico

leahy

moynihan

centrist

reversals

princetonian

prosecutor



===
P@P

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 4

New items and faded topics

Meteor rise of "Gingrich" had an equally hasty retreat on Google. #1 last week and #30 this week. The interesting new entrant for this week is Letterman of the TV talk show fame. Do you think that is the amount of time it takes for Letterman's writers to come up with a good line on this topic?

www.foxnews.com keeps coming back up. I suppose this confirms its position as the voice of the opposition to her nomination.

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

sotomayorhtml

www.foxnews.com

justices

sotomayorâ

courts

nominees

facility

concerns

serving

issued

cityâ

ended

ricans

served

moved

rican

hearings

filed

krimstock

sotomayor


www.foxnews.com

sotomayor

sotomayorâ

sonia

souter

online.wsj.com

scotus

scotusblog

gillibrand

gingrich

nominee

judgeship

schumer

ginsburg

supreme

justices

krimstock

nomination

hispanic

racist


scotus

palin

gillibrand

gingrich

schumer

obama

scotusblog

justices

gop

souter

rulings

politico

republicans

nominee

cuomo

blotter

sotomayor

nightline

letterman

unanimous



===
P@P

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 3

New items and faded topics

It is interesting to see how the three search engines find relevant. The new item that caught my eye for this week was the word "Gingrich" which was not in the top 20 from the prior weeks. This week, it showed up as top 20 in all three.

On the other hand, "www.huffingtonpost.com" completely disappeared in the result; not just the top 20 but the top 1,000 entries. I wonder if this means that www.huffingtonpost.com's voice is being overwhelmed?

More on the results

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

gingrich

sotomayorhtml

rulings

judges

questioning

nominees

malesko

americans

proceedings

sotomayor

sotomayorâ

matters

ricans

helped

upheld

princetonian

issued

correctional

criticized

aspects


www.foxnews.com

sonia

sotomayorâ

sotomayor

souter

online.wsj.com

www.newsday.com

scotusblog

granholm

gillibrand

malesko

gingrich

nominee

schumer

ginsburg

supreme

judgeship

justices

krimstock

upheld


schumer

gillibrand

granholm

obama

justices

hispanics

gingrich

correctional

scotusblog

republicans

gop

souter

rulings

politico

nominee

judgeship

racist

centrist

leahy

reversals

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index - Week 2

Yahoo vs. Google

It is always interesting to compare the results. While I expect the results to converge on the topic over time, it seems that we are still in the early stage in this discussion.

What is particularly interesting is to see Yahoo seems to list more news outlet as a key term than Google. On the other hand, the ranking of the news outlet is different between the two.

Notes, Technical and Otherwise

I was having some technical difficult generating data from Microsoft's Live Search. Hope to get it fixed in time for next week's queries.

A reminder, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine, please let me know at yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com.

Update: 2009-06-03
Thanks to the technology team, Microsoft results were collected and added to this list.

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft

democrats

www.huffingtonpost.com

ruled

sotomayor

www.foxnews.com

hispanics

americans

courts

lawyers

seeks

granholm

died

upheld

questioning

doctor

dissented

nation

souter

helped

sotomayorâ


sotomayorâ

sotomayor

www.foxnews.com

sonia

souter

www.newsday.com

nominee

upheld

malesko

www.huffingtonpost.com

justices

granholm

ginsburg

supreme

gillibrand

krimstock

hispanic

nomination

judgeship

claret


schumer

obama

granholm

hispanics

justices

correctional

gillibrand

republicans

gop

rulings

souter

centrist

unanimous

upheld

nominee

reversals

leahy

www.huffingtonpost.com

reversed

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Sotomayor Web Chatter Index

Catching Sonia Sotomayor

As you may recall from the How to catch a spy entry, PARC has developed a technology that can automatically infer what are the relevant words to a particular topic.

It was announced earlier today that Ms Sotomayor had been nominated for an appointment to the US Supreme Court. I thought it would be interesting to run a regular scan of the web chatter to find out what are the words that web-tizens consider relevant to Ms Sotomayor.

Notes, Technical and Otherwise

This is based on results from three of the most popular search engines - Google, Yahoo, and Microsoft. As a technology geek, it is interesting to see how different engines deal with the same data corpus from the internet.

Before going into the actual results, it is also worth noting that since this is literally day one of the web chatter, there is likely to be some divergence on the results. I would speculate that the results would converge over time, but we shall find out!

Finally, if you are interested in finding out more about the result details or the inference engine, please let me know at "yfjuan (at) parc (dot) com"

Results (top 20 terms ranked in the order of relevance with the most relevant on top)










GoogleYahooMicrosoft
2009/politics/05/26

justices

sotomayor

presser

nominate

nominees

nominations

nominated

appeals

ruled

sotomayorâ

believes

decisions

alito

employee

gillibrand

21st

fourth

sekulow

claim

sotomayorâ

sotomayor

souter

scotus

justices

sonia

ginsburg

scotusblog

www.cnn.com

alito

rel

cabranes

bader

nominee

rosen

gillibrand

sekulow

breyer

www.huffingtonpost.com

leahy

sotomayor

court

â

she

her

supreme

judge

sonia

obama

from

new

2009

law

may

york

nomination

who

has

president

us